| YEAR | NAME | COLLEGE/UNIVERSITY |
| 2010 | Gabrielle Brixey | Lesley University |
| 2013 | Cady Brazelton | Ottawa University |
| 2015 | Kayla Day | Webster University |
| 2016 | Valerie Romero | McPherson College |
| 2017 | Chase Martinez | Hiram College |
| 2023 | Emma Silva | Florida Memorial University |
| 2024 | Alyssa Maldonado | Waldorf University |
| 2024 | Geneva Molina | Waldorf University |
| 2024 | Josilynn Alvarez | Corban University |